Beta

Meta Advantage+ in 2025: The Pros, Cons, and What Marketers Need to Know

Meta Advantage+ automates audience targeting, creative testing, and budget allocation—but is it worth it? Explore the benefits, challenges, and best practices for 2025.
Dan Pantelo

Meta Advantage+ ads provide marketers with algorithmic-powered campaigns designed to automate various aspects of advertising, from audience targeting to creative optimization.

Advantage+ builds upon the previous Automated Ads platform, incorporating powerful machine learning capabilities to handle both Facebook and Instagram ad campaign decisions that traditionally required manual oversight.

As with most new tools, the promise of automation comes with both significant benefits and notable limitations that are important for marketers and growth specialists to understand - and that’s what we’ll break down in this article! 

Understanding Meta Advantage+

If you’re running ads on Meta and still manually setting up every campaign, you’re doing way too much work. Advantage+ uses AI to automate audience targeting, creative testing, and budget allocation. The promise is that your campaigns will automatically find the best people to show your ads to and optimize for in real time. More conversions, more scale, less guesswork.

Yet many advertisers are torn, with many Reddit threads and advertisers on X sharing both drastic wins and losses after implementing these campaigns.

Unlike manual campaigns, Meta Advantage+ automates targeting, testing, and budget allocation for better ad performance.
Unlike manual campaigns, Meta Advantage+ automates targeting, testing, and budget allocation for better ad performance.

The Advantages of Meta Advantage+

Improved Campaign Performance

Meta Advantage+ has impressive results for certain advertising objectives by continuously analyzing performance data across Meta's network, making real-time adjustments to improve campaign efficiency. Many advertisers report seeing lower cost-per-acquisition (CPA) rates and higher return on ad spend (ROAS) after implementing Advantage+.

Time and Resource Efficiency

One of the biggest advantages of Meta Advantage+ is how much time it saves advertisers. Instead of manually tweaking campaigns, advertisers can let Meta’s AI handle the heavy lifting.

This means fewer hours spent adjusting targeting, bids, and placements—allowing marketers to focus on creative strategy and higher-level decision-making.

For businesses running multiple campaigns, this automation can significantly streamline workflows and free up valuable resources.

Budget Allocation Across Ad Sets

Traditionally, advertisers would create multiple campaigns within their Meta Ads Manager accounts to test different creative and audience strategies, each with an explicit budget assigned to it. 

Line-item-level budget allocation allows for control but also limits the potential for a campaign that outperforms others to receive more budget without manual intervention. Inversely, an underperforming campaign could be receiving the same, if not more, budget than the campaign that would have driven more conversions and ROAS.

A Meta Advantage+ campaign can represent just one line item within your ad account that dynamically shifts budget between different ad sets based on real-time performance.

If one audience or creative is driving more conversions at a lower cost, the system will allocate more spend there automatically. This prevents overspending on underperforming ads and ensures that the budget is always being used efficiently. Instead of constantly checking and adjusting spend manually, advertisers can rely on the AI to optimize allocation for the best results.

Audience Targeting Optimization

Rather than relying on predefined audience segments, Advantage+ leverages Meta’s vast data network to find the best possible users for each ad. The AI continuously refines targeting based on engagement, conversions, and other key signals. This means campaigns can reach high-intent users more effectively, often outperforming traditional interest or demographic-based targeting. For advertisers, this reduces the trial-and-error process and helps maximize reach to the right audience.

Meta Advantage+ optimizes audience targeting for better reach and conversions.
Meta Advantage+ optimizes audience targeting for better reach and conversions.

Placement Selection and Optimization

Advantage+ automatically selects the best placements across Meta’s platforms—Facebook, Instagram, Messenger, and Audience Network—based on where ads are performing best. If a particular audience is engaging more with Stories or Reels rather than the Feed, the system will prioritize those placements. This ensures that every impression is served in the most effective environment, increasing the likelihood of engagement and conversions.

Bid Adjustments Based on Performance

Instead of setting static bids, Advantage+ adjusts them dynamically in real-time to maximize efficiency. When the system detects an opportunity to win an auction at a lower cost, it increases bids accordingly. Likewise, if costs start rising, it pulls back to avoid overspending. This constant bid optimization helps advertisers maintain competitive ad performance without having to constantly monitor and tweak bidding strategies manually.

Rapid Testing and Learning

The system's ability to quickly test multiple variations and learn from results enables faster optimization than manual management could achieve. This is particularly valuable when launching new campaigns or entering new markets.

The Limitations and Challenges

Loss of Control

Perhaps the most significant drawback is the reduced control over campaign specifics. 

Advertisers must surrender certain decisions to the AI, which can be particularly challenging for brands with specific targeting requirements or strict brand guidelines. While tools like Marpipe can help maintain creative control through automated yet brand-consistent ad generation, the targeting and delivery aspects remain largely in Meta's hands.

Limited Transparency

Meta Advantage+ operates as something of a black box, making it difficult to understand exactly why certain decisions are made. This lack of transparency can complicate reporting and make it challenging to apply learnings to other marketing channels.

Creative Constraints

While the system can optimize delivery, it may not fully understand nuanced brand messaging or complex product stories. 

This is where supplementary tools become crucial - Marpipe helps maintain creative quality and brand consistency while working within Meta Advantage+'s framework at scale.

Marpipe’s platform allows you to upload your product feed and create dynamic product ads that can scale limitlessly and feed Advantage+ campaigns with the creative it needs to continuously test and optimize. 

Best Practices for Meta Advantage+

Phasing Implementation

A phased rollout helps ensure a smooth transition to Meta Advantage+, starting with lower-risk campaigns and measuring performance against clear benchmarks like CPA and ROAS.

Regular monitoring is crucial, as AI optimization is powerful but still requires human oversight to align with broader marketing goals. 

Balancing Automation and Control

The key to success is blending automation with strategic control. While Meta Advantage+ optimizes targeting, placements, and bidding, advertisers should focus on creative execution. Pairing Advantage+ with Marpipe allows for scalable creative testing while still leveraging Meta’s AI-powered delivery. 

Campaign Structure

Even with automation, a strong campaign foundation is essential. Clearly defining objectives, using high-quality creative assets, and ensuring accurate conversion tracking enable the AI to optimize effectively.

For product-based campaigns, maintaining a well-structured product catalog prevents inefficiencies and ensures dynamic product ads display correctly. Solid groundwork ensures that automation enhances rather than hinders campaign performance.

Creative Strategy

A diverse creative strategy is crucial to making the most of Meta Advantage+. Testing multiple variations—images, videos, and messaging angles—helps maximize engagement across different audience segments. Marpipe’s dynamic templates streamline creative production while maintaining brand consistency. Regularly refreshing assets and tracking performance metrics prevent ad fatigue and ensure continued optimization over time.

Examples of creative variations that can be created through Marpipe 
Examples of creative variations that can be created through Marpipe 

Wrapping it up

Meta Advantage+ represents both an opportunity and a challenge for advertisers. While it offers significant benefits in terms of efficiency and optimization, success requires a strategic approach that balances automation with human oversight. By combining Meta Advantage+ with creative automation tools like Marpipe, advertisers can maintain brand control while leveraging the power of AI-driven optimization.

To maximize results, focus on:

1. Setting clear objectives and benchmarks

2. Maintaining creative quality and brand consistency

3. Regular monitoring and analysis

4. Strategic use of complementary tools and platforms

The future of digital advertising lies in finding the right balance between automation and human creativity. Meta Advantage+ is a powerful tool, but it's most effective when used as part of a comprehensive strategy that includes robust creative automation and human oversight.

Boost ad performance in days with a 7 day free trial.
Claim Trial

How to Run a Multivariate Test

The Beginner's Guide

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Tiffany Johnson Headshot

How to Run a Multivariate Test
The Beginner's Guide

Plus, Get our Weekly
Experimentation newsletter!

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

We run DPA for the world’s biggest brands… and then we share the important things with you.
Join 10k other marketers and subscribe to the Catalog Cult - the world’s best newsletter about catalog ads.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Are you crazy...

about catalog ads? You’re not alone. Join over 10,000 other marketers in The Catalog Cult - the world’s best newsletter about catalog ads.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.